mgcarley
Founder, Hayai Broadband
as per agreement sharing is allowed.. so its within 27.1
Please point to me in the agreement the paragraph where sharing is allowed.
Does MTNL give me service card??? no.. so how come 27.2 become applicable?? and even if its applicable... WHO told you that it is transferrable even to members of the house? this you assumed right? NON_TRANSFERABLE means non-transferable to ANYONE... did they say MEMBERS allowed?? so if connection is in ur dads name.. LEGALLY you cant use it. but dont tell me that household is IMPLIED.
A lot is implied under contract law, but one thing that is not it letting your neighbours piggyback on your connection.
Going back to the insurance issue, if that's all in your father's name, then if your computer gets stolen, then you'll be making the claim under his name, even if you paid for the device. But your neighbour couldn't claim for his under your father's name.
and i am not transferring anything to my friend... its still under my name and still in use by me. even mobile SIM cards are non-transferrable,... that doesnt mean i cant allow my friend to use my mobile and make calls...
You're assuming you have the right to do that. In reality, you don't.
mobile is mine.. broadband is mine
That is not entirely accurate - you rent the right to use a particular phone number and use of the providers network so long as you are alive and paying the bill. It's not YOURS.
mobile phone is under my name... broadband line is under my name... i.e. i have not tranferred it.
The physical device may be yours, but if your mobile phone and broadband line is under your name, then you are merely the one licensed to use the connection. MTNL or any ISP may revoke that license at any time without warning if they can come up with the right reasons.
my friend is making the call...my friend is sharing the connection (because MTNL said sharing is allowed)
Again, features list yes. Contract no.
its simple..nothing is violated.. OR tranferred to him.
You're assuming you have the right to allow someone outside of your household (designated address) to utilize a connection which is contracted to you. In reality, you don't. While IMO casual usage isn't worth worrying about, were you to set up a LAN cable between your two properties for the purpose of sharing, that *would* be worth worrying about.
prove me that i am re-selling it to my friend or getting commercial benefits and ISP will get the right to disconnect my connection.
I'm not saying that you are, but if MTNL decided to take the action of disconnecting you based on evidence that you had been sharing your connection with your neighbour, then they would be well within their rights and you would surely lose if you took them to court. In fact, I doubt any lawyer would even take the case.
Please point to me in the agreement the paragraph where sharing is allowed.
Does MTNL give me service card??? no.. so how come 27.2 become applicable?? and even if its applicable... WHO told you that it is transferrable even to members of the house? this you assumed right? NON_TRANSFERABLE means non-transferable to ANYONE... did they say MEMBERS allowed?? so if connection is in ur dads name.. LEGALLY you cant use it. but dont tell me that household is IMPLIED.
A lot is implied under contract law, but one thing that is not it letting your neighbours piggyback on your connection.
Going back to the insurance issue, if that's all in your father's name, then if your computer gets stolen, then you'll be making the claim under his name, even if you paid for the device. But your neighbour couldn't claim for his under your father's name.
and i am not transferring anything to my friend... its still under my name and still in use by me. even mobile SIM cards are non-transferrable,... that doesnt mean i cant allow my friend to use my mobile and make calls...
You're assuming you have the right to do that. In reality, you don't.
mobile is mine.. broadband is mine
That is not entirely accurate - you rent the right to use a particular phone number and use of the providers network so long as you are alive and paying the bill. It's not YOURS.
mobile phone is under my name... broadband line is under my name... i.e. i have not tranferred it.
The physical device may be yours, but if your mobile phone and broadband line is under your name, then you are merely the one licensed to use the connection. MTNL or any ISP may revoke that license at any time without warning if they can come up with the right reasons.
my friend is making the call...my friend is sharing the connection (because MTNL said sharing is allowed)
Again, features list yes. Contract no.
its simple..nothing is violated.. OR tranferred to him.
You're assuming you have the right to allow someone outside of your household (designated address) to utilize a connection which is contracted to you. In reality, you don't. While IMO casual usage isn't worth worrying about, were you to set up a LAN cable between your two properties for the purpose of sharing, that *would* be worth worrying about.
prove me that i am re-selling it to my friend or getting commercial benefits and ISP will get the right to disconnect my connection.
I'm not saying that you are, but if MTNL decided to take the action of disconnecting you based on evidence that you had been sharing your connection with your neighbour, then they would be well within their rights and you would surely lose if you took them to court. In fact, I doubt any lawyer would even take the case.
