What will happen if I use 33W charger in 10W phone ?

Messages
77
Location
Kerala
ISP
BSNL Fiber
I bought POCO M2 Pro, which comes with 33W adapter. 11V * 3A = 33W. I have an old Redmi Note 4 device, which uses 5v * 2A = 10W adapter to charge. What will happen if I connect my 10W phone into 33W adapter ?

33W charger Description given below.

WhatsApp Image 2020-09-13 at 2.58.14 PM.jpeg
 
Messages
4,399
Location
@socrateszero Mumbai
ISP
Jio Fiber. FTTH
As to how things are unpredictable 2 Asus max pro M1 & 1 max pro M2 suddenly got swollen battery during the current lockdown. Always used company chargers, no games played on any of them & never kept on charge overnight. The 2 M1's we could flog as ecommerce sites opened up fr my area but not the service centers. The M2 just recd it battery last week though it went bad in April. Net result 3 new phones.
The M2 was 13 months old when problems started & the M1's were 17 & 19 months old.
 
Last edited:
Messages
4,399
Location
@socrateszero Mumbai
ISP
Jio Fiber. FTTH
Considering that they sold over a million M1/M2 phones, it's a big shock to the customers as this was never really addressed. I have spoken to senior people in that organization & I am not impressed at all. & they promised replacements for M2 users whose phone got stuck in boot loop but almost none got that. Ask @krish_88 . And they have got away with it.
 


krish_88

Regulars
Messages
1,473
Location
Mumbai
ISP
Airtel XStream Fiber
Considering that they sold over a million M1/M2 phones, it's a big shock to the customers as this was never really addressed. I have spoken to senior people in that organization & I am not impressed at all. & they promised replacements for M2 users whose phone got stuck in boot loop but almost none got that. Ask @krish_88 . And they have got away with it.
Their last update screwed up my device. Luckily i had a backup. They seem to very ignorant and never acknowledge the issue.. Yes, There have been reports of ppl getting the promised replacements... This hasnt happened in my case. I have decided not to take chances with Asus in the near future.
 


Messages
514
Location
Sector 83, Gurgaon
ISP
Airtel FTTH
For anyone who thinks that only voltage matters & not the amperage, I would like to say only one thing. A automobile spark plug cable carries anywhere from 15 to 25 kilo volts but ppl who feel it (including yours truly) live to tell the tale only because the amperage is v v low. If it was higher I wouldn't be typing this.😁😁
No offense but you might be confusing things here, no one is saying amperage does not matter, but what we are saying is that the current pulled by a circuit depends upon its resistance and potential.

V=I*R should be enough to explain this
Given that V is constant and R is a function of temperature(T) and battery percentage(P), (obviously not as simple as that, length of wire etc also matters)
V=I*f(T, P), I (current) = V/f(T, P)
as f(T, P) is a function by definition (for set T x P x R, for each element combination t, p -> T x P, there exists a unique r -> R)

Notice that only one of the variable on right side of the 2nd equation depends upon the charger and that is potential difference, other variable is dependent on circuitry of the mobile.
You don't need to consider any internal resistance of the charger, as the voltage outside it is known (and hopefully constant given its a good quality charger)
therefore at any given battery percentage and temperature, I (current) will remain constant.

It is physically impossible to provide more current to a given circuit at a given electric potential difference by changing the charger.
 
Messages
514
Location
Sector 83, Gurgaon
ISP
Airtel FTTH
Also, the lipo battery used inside most mobile phones can easily give max current of 50 A (generally much more than that, 100+ A), that's around 220w at full charge, if max amperage was a problem, your phone would already have been damaged.
Also the normal AC socket in you house can deliver max current of 10A (RMS) safely, does it mean that anything plugged into that socket will consume an average of 10A?
 
Last edited:
Messages
4,399
Location
@socrateszero Mumbai
ISP
Jio Fiber. FTTH
My post was basically to a comment that 'current does not matter'
And like I have said I prefer to err on the side of caution 😀
Are you sure that normal AC sockets deliver 10A? I always thought that our domestic electrical sockets come in 5A & 15A size🤔
 
Last edited: